Ploog, B. O. (2001). Effects of primary reinforcement on pigeons’ initial-link responding under a concurrent-chains schedule with nondifferential terminal links. Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 76, 75-94.

The effect of primary reinforcement on initial-link responding under concurrent-chains schedules with nondifferential terminal links was assessed in 12 pigeons. The initial and terminal links were variable-interval schedules (always the same for both alternatives). The positions (left or right key) of the initial-link stimuli (red or green) were randomized while the correlation between color and food amount remained constant within each condition. The terminal-link stimuli were always presented on the center key. Except in two control groups and conditions, the terminal-link stimuli were the same color (nondifferential, blue or yellow). Over six conditions, the differences in food amount and the durations of the initial- and terminal-link schedules were manipulated. In 57 of 60 cases, birds generated choice proportions above .50 in favor of the initial-link stimulus that was correlated with the larger reinforcer. There was some indication that preference increased with shortened terminal-link durations. Because the terminal-link stimuli were nondifferential, differential responding in the initial links cannot be explained easily by conditioned reinforcement represented by the terminal-link stimuli. Thus, primary reinforcement has a direct effect on initial-link responding in concurrent-chains schedules.

Key words: primary reinforcement, conditioned reinforcement, choice, memory marking, reinforcement magnitude, concurrent-chains schedules, pigeon